Knowing When to Say “No”

How can I help? What’s best for you? I can stay late…. I can come in over the weekend. It’s no problem! I can make it work! I’ll shuffle some things around! Yes. Sure. Perfect.

Sound familiar? It’s the refrain of the people-pleaser. The quick yes, the deference to someone—anyone—else’s schedule, the weak or non-existent boundaries. For many, this is a way of life. A 2024 survey of 1,100 American adults found that 48 percent of respondents– 52 percent of women– identified as people-pleasers. 

At first glance, it seems like a great way to get ahead. People-pleasers are typically well-liked and appreciated at work. But the truth is nuanced, explained Hailey Magee, author of Stop People Pleasing and Find Your Power, in a CNBC interview. “I define people-pleasing as the act of putting others’ needs, feelings, wants and dreams first at the expense of your own needs, feelings, wants and dreams,” she said. “So, it’s not just being kind and generous, but it’s sacrificing yourself in the process of doing so.” 

People-pleasing, in fact, is hard work in service to other people’s goals. In an HBR podcast, Magee describes the three predominant ways that people-pleasing shows up at work. 

  • First, it’s in the conversations that you are not having. When people make requests, you say what they want to hear regardless of the cost to you. Rather than sharing your boundaries (perhaps you’re overworked, have plans, or are dealing with an under-functioning team member), you say yes, make it work, and then feel resentful. 

  • Secondly, it’s in the work that is (silently) being taken on. People-pleasers tend to overperform, picking up slack from others and exhibiting perfectionist behavior (I can do it better!). Many people pleasers have a deep-seeded belief that if they aren’t working beyond their capacity, they aren’t doing enough.

  • Finally, it’s in how we respond to other’s expectations of us. Magee describes this as the most amorphous of the three, but it occurs when we behave according to others’ expectations of our identity. Women especially try not to be seen as being demanding or overreaching, says Magee. And people of color in the workplace might face pressure to code switch or adjust their behavior or dress to fit in with white colleagues.

In a recent conversation on his WorkLife podcast, organizational psychologist and Wharton professor Adam Grant, asked Sherri Lu, founder of the Eldest Daughter Club, how people-pleasing impacted her career. 

Lu described the pressure she felt—as an Asian woman, someone short in stature, and an eldest daughter—to be helpful and agreeable when teammates asked her for support. Though intellectually she knew she needed to say no sometimes, it was difficult for her. This came to a head when she had a sit-down with her new manager and was surprised to learn that she was not on track for a much-wanted promotion, despite her heavy workload. Her manager laid out the uncomfortable truth: Lu wasn’t on track because she was spending her time working on others’ projects, rather than prioritizing her own high-impact work. Lu realized she had to start saying no to others, if she wanted to accomplish her goals. 

“It actually doesn't help you to be the most easygoing person in the office,” she told Grant. “Everyone's gonna like you, but that won't get you anywhere.” Lu asked for her manager’s support in saying no, so that she could spend her time on higher-value activities that would support her case for promotion.

Making a necessary re-frame.

Most people-pleasers believe that they act this way because they care about others. But the first step in reforming this damaging behavior might be to accept that this is not wholly accurate. Recently, on his Substack, Grant, identified people-pleasing as a “self-focused” behavior. 

He wrote, “When we bend over backward to accommodate others at the expense of our own needs, it’s because we depend on them for self-esteem. Our sense of self-worth rests on their validation. It’s not about their feelings; it’s about how their feelings make us feel... We do it because we’re uncomfortable making others uncomfortable.”

So, with this in mind, what’s the best way forward? 

First and foremost, you need to know when to say “no.” Two tactics for determining this: 

  • Identify where you want to go. Without clear priorities, it’s easy to take on every task and find yourself working extremely hard without getting anywhere in your career. Instead, start defining your goals and considering what experiences you need to achieve them. Consider also that each time you say yes or no, it is communicating your boundaries to others. On his WorkLife podcast, Grant said, “Setting boundaries isn't a display of disrespect. It's an expression of self-respect. It's not about letting others down. It's about standing up for yourself.” 

  • Notice your own feelings. People-pleasers tend to be the last to know that they’re overworked and burning out, as they are often more sensitive to other people’s feelings than their own. Magee recommends defining signposts that you’re overextending and frequently checking yourself against them. For example, notice how you feel when you go to work. Are you resentful, exhausted, or unmotivated? Notice what your free time looks like: Did you work out this week? Did you see your friends or family? If you envision your current state played out over time (six months, a year, five years): Are your current efforts sustainable? Healthy? Do they support your short and longer-term goals? If not, it’s time for an adjustment.

Once you know you want to say “no,” do it strategically: 

  • Be clear about new boundaries. Pre-defining the types of requests you will not accept reduces decision-stress and allows you to decline in an impersonal manner, according to Grant. “I’m sorry, I don’t take on [specific request] any longer” clearly communicates that you have a boundary rather than a lack of interest in helping out the requestor.   

  • Offer a lighter lift. To take the sting out of a no, for you and the recipient, Grant suggests making a point to “convey care.” Volunteering to do something less taxing, for example, like sharing a template or another useful resource, could benefit others without costing you much. 

  • Connect others. While it may sound obvious, many people hesitate to make referrals, says Grant. This may be in part because it’s nice to be seen as the expert, but recommending someone else for a task is still helping people get things done.

In conclusion, saying “no” is just as crucial to your career as saying “yes.” Do it thoughtfully and kindly, of course, but don’t be afraid to do it. In the wise words of Grant: “Saying no is not selfish. It's an act of self-preservation.”